It's amusing that, when Consuela is thinking of an attractive teen idol, she comes up with, umm, Tony Curtis. I mean, it's 1967 (seeing as Daydream Believer has just been released)...Admirable discipline in avoiding Beatles references so far, though.
In my experience with teenage girls and having been one myself, I can tell you they develop crushes on all kinds of people. I had crushes on actors way older than I was when I was a teen. Consuela likes those types of men for a reason. Her crush choices are intentional. And I remember Consuela playing the side B from Sgt. Pepper's in one of the earlier episodes. I also chose "Blue Jay Way" as one of the episode titles/songs, so I'm not avoiding the Beatles completely.